How to play
- Read a question out loud.
- Everyone picks a side: raise a hand, or move to that side of the room.
- Each side gets ten seconds to defend its choice. Then read the next one.
25 Christmas Would You Rather questions
- Would you rather build a snowman or have a snowball fight?
- Would you rather open one present on Christmas Eve or open them all on Christmas morning?
- Would you rather be one of Santa’s elves or be one of his reindeer?
- Would you rather eat only gingerbread for a week or eat only candy canes for a week?
- Would you rather wear an ugly Christmas sweater every day in December or never wear one again?
- Would you rather have a real Christmas tree or have a perfect fake one?
- Would you rather wrap all the presents or untangle all the fairy lights?
- Would you rather spend Christmas on a sunny beach or spend it in a snowy cabin?
- Would you rather sing a carol solo in front of everyone or dance alone to a Christmas song?
- Would you rather get socks for every present or get nothing but chocolate?
- Would you rather ride in Santa’s sleigh or tour Santa’s workshop?
- Would you rather have hot cocoa with marshmallows or have it with whipped cream?
- Would you rather have snow every day of winter or never see snow again?
- Would you rather know what all your presents are or be surprised by every present?
- Would you rather live inside a snow globe for a day or live inside a gingerbread house for a day?
- Would you rather cook Christmas dinner for 20 people or wash all the dishes afterwards?
- Would you rather decorate the tree with only tinsel or decorate it with only candy canes?
- Would you rather have a pet reindeer or have a pet penguin?
- Would you rather watch the same Christmas film every day or never watch a Christmas film again?
- Would you rather always give the perfect gift or always receive the perfect gift?
- Would you rather have Christmas twice a year or have your birthday twice a year?
- Would you rather be Santa for one night or be an elf for a whole year?
- Would you rather eat Christmas dinner backwards, dessert first or eat it with no cutlery?
- Would you rather have a white Christmas with no presents or a green Christmas with presents?
- Would you rather go carol singing door to door or host the whole family at your home?
All 100 questions as printable cards
Instant PDF download on Etsy. A4 and US Letter included. Print at home and play the same evening.